Photo: Julie Larsen
Mangaluru, April 7, 2020: Following widespread reports that a tiger at the Bronx Zoo in New York has been infected with Novel Coronavirus, renowned Indian tiger expert and wildlife biologist Dr. K. Ullas Karanth has said that the issue is being blown out of proportion.
In an article titled “A note on Covid-19 detected in a tiger in the Bronx Zoo” published today in his blog on the website of Centre for Wildlife Studies, Dr Karanth has opined that Coronavirus is not likely to pose a serious threat to tiger population. On the other hand due to a sudden drop in surveillance of protected areas in the wake of national lockdown, India’s wildlife is under serious threat from poachers who have set out on a rampage, he has warned.
The following is the full text of his article.
A note on Covid-19 detected in a tiger in the Bronx Zoo.
Dr. K. Ullas Karanth
Having retired after working for 30 years with Wildlife Conservation Society, which also runs the Bronx Zoo, this report brought back memories of the famed Tiger Mountain exhibit, the tigers like Nadia displayed in it, and more importantly, many of the keepers, veterinarians and curators, my colleagues whose dedication is unmatched in the zoo world.
However, I do believe from the perspective of wild tiger conservation in India, that the issue is being blown out of proportion in the media although this may be out of genuine concern. Although I am not a specialist in viral transmission, it is well known that coronaviruses do affect other mammal species and transmission across species, including from and to humans are well-known and recorded. This specific virus is known to affect domestic cats and it is no surprise tigers can get it too.
However, given that wild tiger populations have high birth rates and high annual mortality rates (up to 20% based on my studies), coronavirus related threats are highly unlikely to cause tiger population declines. There are many other even more virulent infections like rabies, canine distemper etc floating around them for decades with practically no impact on tiger population densities. I find the excessive focus and impractical instructions issued by higher officials have received far too much media attention compared to an emergent real threat to tigers as a consequence of the virus-related lockdown.
In some of the best tiger habitats in the Western Ghats, there appears to be a surge in local poaching, with hunting of tiger’s prey species ratcheting up, because patrol intensity and protection have declined under the early instructions under the lockdown. Other social factors are also contributing to this surge. Unemployed rural workers, deprived of wages and sources of domestic animal protein, are once again turning to wild meat as was the case in the 1950s and 60s. The police being busy otherwise and forest officials facing constraints of movement, courts being closed, etc, are emboldening a new wave of poachers, as recent reports from Kodagu and Shivamogga show. This resurgence of poaching, once unleashed, will be hard to prosecute and control given other social pressures in play. The mass media and senior officials would do well to focus on this poaching issue as a part of Covid-19 responses rather than worry excessively about imagined tiger population declines resulting from the virus.