mangalore today
name
name
name
Friday, March 29
Genesis Engineersnamename

 

Titanic: A legacy of human error

Titanic: A legacy of human error


www.mangaloretoday.com

Apr 9, 2012: They’re 100 years apart but key moments are remarkably similar, a ship taking on water, passengers fleeing their cabins in a panic, widespread confusion over how to best evacuate a vessel in crisis.

One ship hit an iceberg, the other rammed into a rocky reef. Both drew collective disbelief at the loss of life at the time.

More than 1,500 people died when the Titanic sank in 1912. A century later, 32 were killed when a luxury cruise ship, the Costa Concordia, was shipwrecked off the Tuscan coast in January. The number of victims in the 2012 incident pales in comparison, but it was a wakeup call for many who believed large-scale ocean disasters were a phenomenon of the past.

 

Titanic

 

Looking back at a century of marine innovation since the Titanic, observers agree that while what’s arguably the most famous ocean disaster triggered many changes at sea, the prevalence of human error is one of its most lasting legacies.

"It’s not a question of building better ships or building better technology. The fact is people make mistakes," says Joe Scanlon, who has been researching disasters for years and directs the emergency communications research unit at Carleton University in Ottawa.

 

Titanic-100

 

For the Titanic, those mistakes included not slowing the ship in icy water, not having enough lifeboats and not having wireless radio operators at their stations around the clock.

 

Titanic 100yrs

 

Those particular errors triggered a series of changes. Ships now have lifeboats that can accommodate every occupant, radio stations are staffed at all times and shipping lanes avoid ice-routes with the help of the International Ice Patrol, founded after the Titanic went down.

Additionally, two years after the Titanic sank, the world’s maritime nations also adopted an international convention for Safety of Life at Sea, or SOLAS, which is still in effect today.

What hasn’t changed, however, is the role people play when things go wrong.

Some who have studied the Titanic point in particular to the ship’s captain, Edward Smith.

"I don’t think he should have ever been appointed captain," says Scanlon, adding that the Titanic’s maiden voyage was meant to be Smith’s last before retirement. "This was a guy who was banging into things in his career."

Ten decades later, many are scrutinizing the Costa Concordia’s captain, who is being investigated for alleged manslaughter, causing a shipwreck and abandoning ship during the evacuation. He has denied wrongdoing and claimed the reef that ripped a hole in his ship wasn’t marked on charts.

In hindsight, however, alleging a ship’s captain is the key person at fault is all too convenient, warns one Titanic enthusiast.

"The only truth has gone down with the ship," said Norm Lewis, president and founder of the Canadian Titanic Society. "As far as I’m concerned the (Titanic’s) captain did everything he could."

Overconfidence in a ship’s mechanical prowess hasn’t changed though, said Lewis.

"With this Costa Concordia I think what they’re doing in a way is making the same mistake they made back in 1912. They’re thinking that because of modern technology they can do this, they can do that."

Courtesy: The Canadian Press


Write Comment | E-Mail To a Friend | Facebook | Twitter | Print
Comments on this Article
A. S. Mathew, U.S.A. Tue, April-10-2012, 9:14
Perhaps the tragedy of Titanic gives us all a great lesson of life; that how foolish pride will destroy us and many other people following us. Even though the Captain got strong warning from many sources to slow down Titanic, but he never slowed down; which killed many people in hours, and the vast majority of them were prominent people of the society. King Solomon, the wisest man ever lived said " Pride goes before destruction, and a haughty spirit before a fall" Proverbs 16:18 (Bible).
Error:NULL
Write your Comments on this Article
Your Name
Native Place / Place of Residence
Your E-mail
Your Comment
You have characters left.
Security Validation
Enter the characters in the image above