Mumbai, Nov 12, 2019: Maharashtra should be placed under President’s Rule, the Union Cabinet has recommended, according to sources. The recommendation follows uncertainty over government formation in the state 20 days after election results on October 24. After the BJP and the Shiv Sena failed to show enough numbers to form a government, Governor Bhagat Singh Koshyari invited the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) of Sharad Pawar to take a shot. The NCP is to give an answer by 8.30 pm today, which is why the recommendation of President’s Rule surprised many. Yesterday, the Shiv Sena failed to produce letters of support from the NCP and the Congress and requested three days to do so, but the Governor did not grant an extension. Instead, the Governor moved on to the NCP, the third largest party in line.
Here’s your 10-point cheatsheet to this big story:
1. The Shiv Sena’s attempts at cobbling an anti-BJP alliance hit a wall with the Congress, after a day of discussions, stating that it needed to hold more discussions with Sharad Pawar. Sonia Gandhi sent her top party leaders to Mumbai for discussions on government formation after speaking to Sharad Pawar on the phone this morning.
2. The Sena’s plans to take power in Maharashtra after ending its alliance with long-term partner BJP are on hold with the Congress holding the key. The Congress leaders had earlier put off their visit. NCP leader Ajit Pawar had told NDTV that his uncle Sharad Pawar had been asked to meet Sonia Gandhi in Delhi instead. Mr Pawar had declined, citing a meeting of NCP MLAs in Mumbai.
3. Though Congress MLAs in Maharashtra favour forming a government with the Sena, the party leadership, especially Sonia Gandhi, is extremely wary of a tie-up with such an ideologically different party, a traditional enemy and one with which it was in direct contest in Mumbai and many regions in Maharashtra in the polls.
4. The Shiv Sena yesterday pulled out its only minister in Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government at the centre to signal its exit from the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA). The Sena’s separation from the BJP was the NCP’s prerequisite for talks between the Maharashtra rivals for a non-BJP alliance.
5. The NCP was ready with its letter of support to the Sena last evening but was left waiting by the Congress. "Whatever decision will be taken will be taken collectively, so we were waiting for Congress response yesterday but it didn’t come, we can’t decide on it alone. There is no misunderstanding, we are together. The Congress is taking time because we didn’t contest with the Shiv Sena," said Ajit Pawar.
6. The Congress is also concerned that the Sena’s divorce with the BJP, its partner of nearly 30 years, may not be permanent. That would put in doubt the sustainability of a Sena-NCP-Congress coalition government.
7. The Uddhav Thackeray-Sonia Gandhi phone call had fueled reports that the Sena had won the Congress’s support. But even as a Sena delegation met with Governor Bhagat Singh Koshiyari, the Congress put out a non-committal statement saying there was no decision yet and it would talk to Sharad Pawar. The Sena was forced to ask the Governor for three more days, which was denied.
8. Sources say in their discussions yesterday, Sharad Pawar told Sonia Gandhi that there was a need for more talks on the contours of supporting the Sena. "NCP is just two seats short of Sena," Mr Pawar reportedly flagged, indicating a reassessment of the Sena’s desire for a full term for its chief minister.
9. Caretaker Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis of the BJP resigned on Friday. On Saturday, as the term of the Maharashtra legislative assembly ended without any resolution, Governor Koshyari invited the BJP to form government. But the BJP opted out of the race accusing the Sena of "betraying the people’s mandate".
10. The BJP won 105 seats in the Maharashtra polls and the Sena 56, which placed them comfortably ahead of the majority mark of 145 in the 288-member assembly. But the allies fell out over the Sena’s demand for rotational chief ministership, in a "50:50" deal it said was discussed with BJP chief Amit Shah. With the NCP’s 54 seats and the Congress’s 44, the Sena will have 154 MLAs on its side. Congress MLAs remain at a resort in Rajasthan’s Jaipur as the leadership wants to avoid a repeat of Goa, where its members crossed over to the BJP.
Governor has recommended President’s rule say sources
Governor Bhagat Singh Koshyari has reportedly recommended President’s Rule in Maharashtra.
Former Union Finance Minister Yashwant Singha criticised the reports, calling the Government of Maharashtra an "agent of the centre" while Congress leader Sanjay Jha said that the "Governor’s decision will be challenged in the courts".
"How can the honourable governor recommend President rule till the time given to NCP doesn’t lapse?" Priyanka Chaturvedi of the Shiv Sena asked.